Going local, in ancient Greece
Hans Beck wins major European research prize
By Neale McDevitt
Hans Beck, a professor of Ancient History, the John MacNaughton Chair of Classics, and the Director of Classical Studies in the Department of History and Classical Studies, knows a little about irony.
“It’s funny that a project on localism has become such a global enterprise,” he says with a smile. “We are working with partners in Europe and around the world. So far, the project entails exchanges with researchers in Classics, Ancient History, Sociology, Anthropology and the Neurosciences. This is a thoroughly interdisciplinary and international project.”
Beck’s project, entitled the ‘Parochial Polis’, is an in-depth exploration of the force of localism in the ancient Greek world. Beck’s research, which sees him collaborating with Peter Funke from the University of Münster in Germany, is supported by the Alexander von Humboldt Foundation’s Anneliese Maier Research Award, worth approximately $400,000.
Expanding worlds lead to more local focus
Ancient Greece went through a number of periods of intense cultural expansion. By the 6th century BCE, Greek city-states had established colonies in areas that today are Italy, France, Spain, Libya and the Black Sea region.
The expansion was such that Cicero, the Roman politician and philosopher, later noted “it were as though a Greek fringe has been woven about the shores of the barbarians.”
ut Beck says that the extension of the geographical boundaries of Hellenicity was counterbalanced, to a certain degree, by a mental reaction toward insulating – and even protecting – these Greek city-states through a growing sense of localism.
“We tend to use the word ‘local’ as a descriptive term to refer to anything from folklore to food, tastes, and traditions. We value local produce or we write local history,” says Beck.
“But the ‘Parochial Polis’ project starts with the assumption that the local is in itself a formative force in human interactions and that humans are exposed to this force without actually realizing it. Their ideas of ‘the local’ steers them in their decision-making practices every day – how they view the world; and how they view events in their immediate environment and in their not so immediate environment, meaning an increasingly globalized world,” says Beck.
Breaking the code of localism
Ancient Greece is particularly fertile ground for this type of research because of the high density of state units in a fairly small natural environment. These city-states were in constant interaction with each other; hence the high degree of interconnecticvity. Yet each city-state also constituted a local world of its own.
“As soon as you look closely, you’ll see xyz city priding itself in one thing and the next city prides itself in the exact opposite,” says Beck. “It’s almost a brand-labeling competition. Sometimes this is about fairly pedestrian and down-to-earth things such as music and dances, or skillsets of local artisans, but all of this also impacts their understanding of politics and how they view and construe narratives of the world around them.
“As the Greek world grew larger, every generation saw goods, ideas, materials, and people travel further, wider and faster. There was an incredible dissemination of knowledge,” says Beck. “But at the same time, there was this very strong preoccupation with and preeminence of the local.
“Why is that? We would like to understand that force,” says Beck. “This is an open-ended investigation in the best terms. I have no idea what the results will be. We are looking at nothing less than the ongoing tension between small worlds and the desire to engage in affairs beyond our comfort zone, beyond the familiarity of our everyday interactions.”
Classical Studies on the rise
On top of making it possible to go full throttle on the ‘Parochial Polis’ initiative, the prize money from the Alexander von Humboldt Foundation means Beck will be able to enlist the help of a lot of people, both from the Department of History and Classical Studies and from abroad.
“The largest portion of the money will go into international collaborations and supported research for our people here,” he says. “This means funded research opportunities for undergraduates, graduates, doctoral students and post-doctoral students. It’s a full slate and that is a really good thing for our department.”
Beck spends a lot of time talking about the Department – and the Classical Studies branch in particular – and the pride in his voice is obvious.
“Classical Studies in this University is in excellent shape. Ours is a small, boutique enterprise with a high-end curriculum, a fantastic exit record and great research projects around it. We make some noise,” says Beck. “Classical Studies makes important contributions to all sorts of conversations in our Faculty and beyond.”
A case in point: Last year the Classical Studies unit organized an event at the Musée de Beaux Arts making cross-cultural comparisons between ancient Greece, Rome and China. A room was booked with a capacity for 120 people but much to Beck’s delight, over 200 people showed up.
“If I walked around the room and asked ‘Why did you come to this Classics talk?’ I would get 200 informed or not so informed opinions. But I’d get opinions. We look at questions and ideas that matter to people and that they can relate to.
“People sometimes ask ‘why study the Classics?’ and we get too defensive,” says Beck. “I would turn that question around and ask ‘”Why not?’”
Greece softens stance on legal action over Parthenon Marbles
Nicola Sullivan, 20.05.2015
Greek cultural minister says route to reclaiming the sculptures should be diplomatic and political
The Greek government has softened its stance on taking legal action to reclaim the Parthenon Marbles, easing a longstanding dispute with the British Museum.
Last week Nikos Xydakis, the Greek cultural minister, told Greek broadcaster Mega TV that the route to retrieving the sculptures should be diplomatic and political, rather than via international courts.
It has been reported that the minister’s announcement came shortly after human rights lawyers at Doughty Street chambers in London advised the Greek government that it should take the British Museum to the International Court of Justice.
When the Museums Journal contacted Doughty Street it was told that the advice could not be shared with the press for reasons of client confidentiality. The Greek Culture Ministry had not responded to requests at the time of going to press.
The British Museum said that it will now be able to “develop existing good relations” with curatorial colleagues in Greece.
A statement sent to the Museums Journal said: "The Parthenon sculptures in London, that represent 30% of the original scheme, are an important representation of ancient Athenian civilisation in the context of world history.
"Each year millions of visitors, free of charge, admire the artistry of the sculptures and gain insight into how ancient Greece influenced – and was influenced by – the other civilisations that it encountered.
"The current division allows different and complementary stories to be told about the surviving sculptures, highlighting their significance within world culture and affirming the place of Ancient Greece among the great cultures of the world.”
In April the UK government turned down a request from the Greek government to enter into mediation, facilitated by Unesco, over the Parthenon Marbles.